The counseling office felt even smaller now — as if the walls had leaned in the moment Seraphine took her seat. Beige paint, soft lamp lighting, the faint hum of the campus AC. Nothing threatening. Nothing sharp.
But Elias could feel the danger anyway.
Two chairs facing each other.
Two players studying the board.
Neither pretending they weren’t playing.
He sat forward, notebook open in his lap, pen resting against the page ready for truth.
Seraphine sat still and composed, one hand wrapped tightly around the strap of her bag like she might drift away without it.
He studied her posture, her breath, the micro expressions that betrayed people more than words ever did.
She didn’t flinch.
Didn’t fidget.
Didn’t fold in on herself the way the others had.
She was made of calm.
And calm could be more dangerous than fear.
He reviewed the pattern quietly in his mind:
Pretty.
Young.
Quiet.
Shy.
Unlikely to report.
Trained by survival to obey.
Every one of Alano’s victims fit the mold.
Seraphine Calderon matched it too — at least at first glance.
Except her eyes.
Not hollow.
Not broken.
Not even dimmed.
Support the creativity of authors by visiting Royal Road for this novel and more.
Her eyes watched the room the way an ocean watched ships — patient and fathomless, letting waves pass overhead while something deeper moved beneath.
Elias cleared his throat.
“Tell me how you knew Dr. Alano.”
Seraphine took her time breathing before she answered — performing hesitation or maybe living it.
“He was a good teacher,” she whispered.
The sentence caught him off guard.
No one else had used good and Alano in the same universe.
“He explained things clearly. He made us understand the subject.”
Elias scribbled the words anyway.
“But,” she continued, voice tightening like a string being drawn, “he also stared too long.”
Her hand found the hem of her skirt. Her fingers twisted it gently, like she could wring the discomfort out.
“He looked at us like he was choosing.”
Elias felt the familiar burn behind his sternum. He nodded without speaking.
She was leading him somewhere.
“One day,” Seraphine said, “he told me I was failing.”
His pulse spiked.
He didn’t move a muscle.
“And that if I didn’t want that to happen…”
Her throat bobbed.
“…I had to do something for him.”
The room felt colder.
Even the bland beige walls seemed to retreat.
Seraphine kept her gaze down — lashes trembling — the very picture of humiliation.
Except Elias couldn’t shake the quiet thought sliding into his mind:
She hasn’t broken once.
She hasn’t cracked.
Every word feels placed.
Carefully.
Surgically.
He stayed silent.
Seraphine, almost timidly, lifted her face — not all the way — just enough for their eyes to collide.
“I was with him the night before he died.”
Elias’s spine straightened.
“You were,” he repeated, making the statement a question.
She nodded, and the pause stretched into something immense.
“You already know what he did to me too.”
A single tear clung stubbornly to her lower lash — refusing to fall.
Elias felt something pull at him — protective instinct, righteous fury, old wounds.
He forced his hands to loosen around the pen.
“And the others…” she whispered, voice shredding softly, “they’re probably relieved he’s dead.”
A slow breath.
“But I’m not.”
Confusion flickered through him.
Not what he expected.
“Why?” Elias asked quietly.
Seraphine finally met his gaze fully — no tremble, no retreat.
“He deserves to live.”
Elias blinked.
Her tone had shifted — gone flat, cold iron beneath velvet.
“What makes you say that?” he asked.
Seraphine didn’t hesitate.
“Because dying is the easy way out.”
A chill rippled across Elias’s skin — scalp to ribs.
“And men like him,” she added, soft as thread unraveling, “do not deserve something easy.”
It was a sentence that didn’t belong to a frightened student.
It belonged to someone making rulings.
Elias tried to speak and found nothing waiting in his throat.
Seraphine tilted her head, the faintest gesture — a thoughtful predator watching a reaction.
“Do you think so, Detective?” she asked lightly.
He swallowed.
She lowered her eyes again, eyelashes brushing her cheeks like innocence reborn.
“Why are you interviewing us anyway?” she murmured. “Do you think one of us pushed him to kill himself?”
No accusation.
No fear.
Just a question wrapped in silk — threaded with something sharper beneath.
Elias stared at her, trying to categorize what he was seeing, and failing at every angle.
For the first time since the first staged body in a motel bed, he felt something unsettlingly new:
He didn’t know whether he was sitting across from a victim… or the person he’d been hunting.
